Current topic: Is the use of AI more beneficial or harmful for both secondary math students and teachers?
Partner: Alina
Why this is important to me:
As mentioned in my previous post, I think this is a really relevant topic that has created quite a bit of anxiety for me as a teacher candidate for what it will mean for my future teaching practice. I feel that my personal exposure to AI and its impacts has been largely negative, but I am very interested in developing this understanding further to see if it would be swayed. I think that there are some ways in which AI can be helpful, and I am very curious to see if these are implemented in math classrooms right now, and if this is benefiting both the students and teachers. Or, conversely, if AI use is largely harmful to student learning, and if math teachers are quite against its use (and then how exactly they are reconciling the inevitable use by students that will occur outside the class). Alina is a bit more pro-AI than I currently am, so I am very eager to have discussions with her and expand our understanding through exploring these differing perspectives. I think it will offer us a deeper insight into both sides of the argument, and lend itself well to this inquiry project. Overall, I feel that this is very relevant for us as future teachers, since it is very unlikely that AI is going away anytime soon, and having a good grasp of its current role in the classroom (and whether this is bad or good) will give us a better jumping off point for our own careers. I hope that our findings will be beneficial not only to our own understanding of AI and its uses, but for our fellow TCs as well.
Some aspects to explore:
Like I outlined in my previous post, I would be very intrigued to compare and contrast the opinions that secondary math students and teachers have. How can AI use be both beneficial and harmful for teachers (i.e. on the admin side vs on the side of assigning outside of class work that could potentially be completed with AI instead of student learning), as well as for students (i.e. as a free tutor vs as a way for students to circumvent learning (and potentially be wrong without realising it)). If after some preliminary research we find that there is too much information on this topic (as it is quite broad), we could narrow it to focusing solely on student vs teacher use (although the difference between the two is quite intriguing to me), or even restricting it to mathematical use only (i.e. no admin side), or certain grades (i.e. higher level math). Overall, there are many avenues this project could go down, but I am particularly interested in the differences in opinions between teachers and students if this is not too broad of a lens.
Some key words and phrases:
AI use for admin tasks for teachers
AI math tutor high school
AI math use issues
AI math use benefits
AI math use teacher opinions
AI math use student opinions
AI use in math school policies
AI use in math
Related areas to not include:
I want to try and narrow the scope of this project to just AI use within math contexts (but including admin tasks for math teachers if this is not too large of a scope), and not include how this is used/its impact in other subjects. I also want to avoid only looking at the negatives or only look at the positives, as I want this to be more of a comparison between the two. Regardless of my own opinions on the subject, I think it’s important to consider both sides, especially since AI will be a part of the worlds we teach in, and it would benefit no one to make blanket statements about its usefulness without even exploring other perspectives.
Other major questions or insights:
I am curious about if there is a difference in opinion between new teachers versus more tenured ones. Is there a more kind opinion of AI from teachers early in their careers (that might stem from not having a ton of experience in the field without it), and does this influence its use in the classroom? As in, does the teacher’s perspectives/opinion of AI influence the students view and how they use it? Does a teacher looking more harshly on AI and banning its use cause students to see it similarly, or conversely are they more inclined to use it but covertly? And vice versa, does a teacher who is more open to AI and discussing its uses in class encourage a more sympathetic view of AI from students, or does it encourage students to see both its benefits and harms? I think this would be interesting to look at since this could have direct applications to our teaching. For instance, if we want to encourage critical use of AI (as I think it’s difficult to completely ban its use and then trust that every student follows that), is it better to have a hyper critical stance on it, or be more open?
No comments:
Post a Comment